Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Revelation 1: The Pathways and Products of Worship

Coming Soon

Introduction to Revelation

Tools, Themes and Tips for Taking on Revelation
Let me start with a confession.  I didn’t want to do Revelation this summer.  I mean, I really didn’t want to.  When Zach and Dan and I started talking about what to take on and they started to gravitate towards revelation, I dragged my feet.  Here’s how bad I didn’t want to do Revelation…when they asked me for a counter proposal…I suggested…Leviticus. 
You know why?  Because I would have literally rather done any of the other 65 books.
You see even though Leviticus is many people’s least favorite book of the Bible, at its worst, is just dull.  Revelation seems to bring out the crazy. 
For any of you who maybe haven’t heard of Revelation, or maybe are new to the Bible all together, it is the final book and without a doubt, strangest, book of the Christian Scriptures and is full of bizarre and often disturbing imagery.
I mean, here are just a few attempts to illustrate passages of this book.
I mean, this text can be disturbing even when it is illustrated in lego dioramas.
And some of us have known or will know perfectly normal people get totally and unhelpfully obsessed with this Revelation…Something I’ve never seen happen with Leviticus.  I mean, seriously, when was the last time you heard of someone going to a seminar on the interpretation of Leviticus or when was the last time you read a fictionalized account of Leviticus? 
Anyway, how did Dan and Zach respond to my counter-proposal. 
Mockery.
So here we are…
But, I’m not alone in my hesitance to take on this book am I.  Dan and Zach notwithstanding, a lot of responsible preachers and students of the scriptures have kept this book at arms length. 
For example, John Calvin, maybe the most careful theologian and Biblical interpreter in the last 600 years, wrote a commentary on every book of the Bible…except revelation.

And maybe, some of you feel similar hesitance about taking on the book of Revelation as I did.  Maybe you’ve tried to read it and found it bizarre and confusing.  I think my friend kind of got to the heart of it when she offered this on my facebook page a little while ago…


And that is really the question…can we answer that question ‘what does this book mean.’  Before it can be helpful, before we find utility in this text to live better lives (which I believe is something we can expect any Biblical text to offer), we have to understand what John means by all these crazy images.
And that is the problem.  While the first generation would have easily understood the conventions and recognized the symbols...for us it is going to take a little more work.
But, before we can dive into the question
“What does revelation mean?”
we have to ask a more basic question.
“How do we decide what any text means?”
_____
So, many of us have websites that we can blow hours on if we’re not careful…one of mine is:
SongMeaning…I can blow hours on this site.
People get on this site and debate what songs mean.
And it can get a little heated.  A lot of songs contain symbolic language makes it a little difficult to know for sure what they are talking about.  It seems like a few years ago, if you went on this site the discussion surrounding the meaning of almost every song was a debate between:
Iraq war/God/a girl
These disagreements were based on vague impressions and mental associations between the words and symbols and the interpreter’s world.
And I always want to ask a very basic question on this site. 
What is our criteria for determining the meaning of a song? 
What are the criteria of evidence and coherence that are sufficient for me to accept an interpretation. 
Are there criteria, or does it boil down to a ‘feeling’ of ‘yeah that one feels right and the others don’t.’
Are there tools we can use to help us get to a less subjective answer to the question “what does this text mean?”
And whenever I hear people talk about what a Biblical text ‘means’, particularly when it is controversial, I have the same question.
Are there any basic criteria that can guide us as when our default method for interpreting texts encounters resistance.
Well, there is one basic principle that Bible Scholars in our movement tend to use as a guide to help them determine the meaning of a text: 
A text can’t mean what it never meant.  
Before we apply a text to our lives, or speculate what it might mean in our time, we have to ask, what did it mean in its original time, place, culture and context.  
One author described the process of interpretation with a phrase he borrowed from a hobbit...in order to understand the scriptures, we have to ‘go there, and back again.’
 And so that is how I am going to organize the balance of our time.  First we are going to give you some tools to ‘go there’ and try to figure out how this text might have functioned in the early church…and then we will talk about how, once we are rooted in that reality, we can ‘come back again’ and find application to our time and context.

So first have to GO THERE.
I. Going There
Revelation isn’t some sort of puzzle that you need to figure out to understand future events…it is a gorgeous work of inspired literature…in a genre that would have been very familiar to those who read it… that, when read against its historical backdrop, speaks words of encouragement and correction into every generation.
The key to what any Biblical text ‘means for you’ is what it ‘meant for its original audience’. And revelation isn’t somehow a special exception.   Look at the opening sentence:
This is first and foremost a book of God speaking encouragement and correction into current events…for the original audience. 
John was a pastor, writing with passionate concern that ordinary men and women (in Asia minor at the close of the first century.  And he while he also wrote a remarkable book…Revelation was almost certainly intelligible to the ordinary men and women who heard it read in the time it was written. It isn’t a sort of puzzle written to the last generation that every intervening generation will get wrong because we don’t have the right current events.
So one way people who talk about Scriptural interpretation talk about it is that there are 2 gaps that we have to bridge before we can hope to understand what a passage “means”
I.       The Literary Gap (it is a different genre of literature than we have ever encountered)
II.     The Historical Gap
So let’s start with the Literary Gap.
I.                 The Literary Gap
So let’s start with the literary gap.  The primary reason that Revelation is so puzzling is that it is a piece of literature that was common in the first century but we are entirely unfamiliar with.
The symbols and literary forms are totally foreign to us.  When we pick up this text which is an inspired text of God’s self disclosure, but it also a stylized piece of first century art, well it would be kind of like handing our i-pod full of Tupac and Radiohead and the flaming lips handing it to the author of this book as he sat on his desert island.  He wouldn’t know where to begin.
Table Activity:
There are 3 clues in the first 4 verses to what kind of literature this is.  Can you find them?
1.    1:1 “revelation”  “which God Gave him to show”  “He made known by sending his angel”
2.    1:3 “prophecy”
3.    1:4 “letter”

1.    1:1 “revelation”/Greek “Apocalypse”
Note: Not the book of Revelations – It is the Revelation – or the Apocalypse
NPR – the summer of the apocalypse
“And there's an odd plethora of Comic Apocalypses (this summer)”

Multiple examples of films about the end of the world or about the end of civilization…including the film that came out last weekend…WWZ
But this is unhelpful because it confuses apocalypse and dystopia.  We have essentially made these synonyms.  A dystopia is a story about the end of the world or the collapse of civilization (either due to disease, or natural disaster, or monsters, or political mismanagement…or in the case of zombies, all of the above) and the social chaos that ensues…or the full on end of the world (e.g. by an asteroid).
Now, don’t get me wrong, I am a sucker for Dystopia…in the last couple years I have read no fewer than 10 dystopic novels (including WWZ the novel the film is based on)…this summer is full of dystopic films…and the television is banking on dystopic shows…but my current favorite piece of dystopic art is the Song Tables and Chairs by Andrew Bird

Dystopia and snacks…sounds like every Baptist seminar on Revelation I have ever been to.
We are fascinated with how civilization will fall and how the world will end.  And when we hear that this book is an “apocalypse” we assume that it is predicting how civilization will fall and how the world will end.
But Apocalyptic ≠ Dystopia
But Apocalyptic is just a type of literature communicated in symbols that would be easy for insiders to understand but would not get them in trouble with outsiders.
The reason that “Apocalypse” is translated into English as “revelation” is because the purpose of an apocalypse is to make current events clear through a series of highly visual symbols and explanations by transcendent messengers.
Reading revelation like it is a straight narrative of the end of the world is like looking at a Picasso painting and coming to one of two conclusions:
i.                   This guy is a terrible artist…or…
ii.                 The world is much stranger than I see it

This great art is totally puzzling to us until we understand the conventions of the genre.  In the same way, we can read revelation as a history document published a few thousand years too early and come to one of two conclusions
i.                   This guy is a raving lunatic…or….
ii.                 The future is going to be very very weird
But if we read revelation as an instance of apocalyptic art…we come away with a much different picture.  First, this is a brilliant piece of art that was written by a loving pastor to churches that were either suffering or compromising in an artistic genre that they would understand.
2.    1:3 “prophecy”
Blessed is the one who reads aloud the words of this prophecy
This is what most people think of…the OT has lots of prophecy…and the NT has one too.
But most people are not familiar enough with OT prophecy to know what to expect from a NT prophecy – the primary purpose of prophecy in the Hebrew Scriptures is not telling the future…if you were to actually calculate the % of old testament prophecy that talks about the future 5% might be too high…and many of those verses talk about the present and future at the same time.
The primary purposes of prophecy are correction and encouragement.
And as you will see…those are the two big themes of Revelation.  This text has hard words of correction for those who are off course and tender words of encouragement for those who are hard pressed.  And a couple chapters about the future.  And, in that way, it is totally in line with the OT prophetic tradition.
3.    1:4 “letter”
Multiple references to the churches stressing this text’s status as a letter.
-v 4 – “John to the seven churches that are in Asia:”
Letters are to a particular place and setting.  To understand what is going on in Paul’s letter to the Corinthians, you need to know a little bit about 1st century Corinth…which leads us to our second gap.
These aren’t the ratings of a simple fisherman stuck on a desert island…this is a complex and inspired work of art…inspired by God to speak correction and encouragement into that generation in such a way that it still matters ion ours…it is a work with a rich, complex, web of symbols, that is so deeply conversant with every thread of OT promise that it is impossible to count the connections with the OT…and it is a work that borrows three different genres that appeal to Hebrew and Roman members of the early church.

II.              The Historical Gap
-The first rule of biblical interpretation– the Bible can never mean what it never meant

-the original context controls meaning – and original meaning sets the parameter for contemporary application – Revelation is not somehow exempt from this process.

This book was written by a pastor in exile to 7 churches that were in what is today Turkey…a region that was firmly under the power of the Roman empire. 

The Roman Empire in the second half of the first century was dominated by two men who were, frankly, crazy: Nero and Domitian.  And part of their madness was not just that they claimed to be God…that was part of the emperor job description…but they demanded to be worshiped on penalty of death. 

Nero and Domitian were separated by a series of emperors who enacted a kind of a ‘don’t ask don’t tell policy.’  If you don’t make trouble we won’t come looking for you.  But the book was written near the end Domitian reign, at kind of the peak of his madness, where he was passing decrees that everyone needed to worship him…or die.  And that was going to go poorly for the Christians who, didn’t really feel like that was something they could do.


But the very worst of it was still to come.  In the next couple hundred years, sporadic persecution would be replaced with empire wide persecution under the reigns of Diocletian.
And so, John writes an apocalyptic, prophetic, letter just as Domitian is about to drop the hammer.  Which means that there are 4 temporal categories that we can file any of the symbols and passages of this book into:
    

How you sort the events of revelation into these bins will determine which of the many possible interpretations you will come to.

So where does this leave us?  Well first we have to ask a question, what would this have meant to the original community it was addressed to.  But it is not enough to leave it there, as a kind of hisotic academic discipline.  Then we have to…
II. Come Back Again
…and ask, given what this meant to the original hearers, how does it speak to us in our context and our generations.
So how do we come back again.
Why didn’t I want to teach Revelation?  Why did it scare our friend?  Why didn’t Calvin write a commentary? 
Well because better men and women have been wrong.  I mean frankly, that is what it comes down to.
But why are so many so hesitant to take this book on…well, its because of those who weren’t.
I mean look at this list of what the ‘enemies’ in Revelation have been identified as over the last two hundred years, often by some of the Chruchs’ best theologians:
Date
Enemy
Author
5th Century
Vandals
Caesarius of Arles*
6th Century
Visigoths
Apringius
7th Century
Arians and Donatists
Bede**
Reformation 16th-20th
Roman Church
Luther, Edwards, etc...
Early 20th  Century
Mussolini and Hitler
Various
1960-70’s
Cold War Figures
Various
Early 1990’s
Gulf War Figures***
Various (including me)
Current
Islamic Terrorists, EU, Multinational corporations






My interpretation of revelation was deeply affected by seeing books that interpreted it as the events of the gulf war that are signaling the end of the world…in a Christian book $1 table a couple years later
It is enough to make a wise and thoughtful person who handles their Bible seriously a little gun shy.
But take a look at that list for a second.  What do all of the armies and movements and figures on that list have in common?  They were all pretty terrifying to the person reading revelation in that time.
Anti-European American sentiment has also recently made the EU and the UN prominent characters in the interpretation of Revelation…and of course…the other political party.

I mean, if Caesarius and Bede and Luther blew it and John Calvin was too cautious to even take it on…what makes me think I’m going to get it right?
So let me ask a question, why are intelligent, well adjusted, humble Christians reluctant to take on Revelation.  Well, because many smarter, more spiritual individuals who have seen its symbols in their generation have been wrong.
I’m always skeptical of preaching that essentially says “the church has believed this for years…but they are wrong.  You should listen to me instead.”
And if they have all been wrong, what are the chances that I am the one who is going to get it right?
But let me pose an alternate way of looking at it.  What if they haven’t all been wrong.  What if they have all been right.  What if the same terrors that John was warning and encouraging the first century church about recur in every generation?
What if Caesarius was right to see the Visigoths in this text?
And Bede was right when he saw the Donotists in these pages?
And later authors who saw the WWII Axis or Cold war powers, or middle eastern oppressors…what if they were right too?
And what if the developing world Christians who have seen the economic power of America as the villain of this book…what if they have been right as well?
You see, by respecting John’s historical and literary context…by recognizing that his symbols largely correspond to political, religious, and military realities of his era…it frees us to see Revelation as practical instructions for how Christians are supposed to deal with oppressing power.
And whatever you fear…John is talking about that.  Whatever is enticing you or intimidating you right now, in this generation…John is talking about that.
And whatever your children and grand-children will fear in 20, 30, or 70 years…John is also talking about that.
Understanding the historic situatedness of Revelation better prepares us to identify its characters in our generation…and profit from it in our time.  Who is our Rome – who are the imperial powers that demand our allegiance that we are called to resist. 
Who is the beast who would compel us with power? 
Who is the cultural prostitute who would entice us with bread and circuses? 
Who is the liar that emerges from chaos as a parody of the lamb. 
Who is the monster that emerges from the land full of propaganda? 
You see, if you take it this way, then you escape the precarious position of saying, every previous generation who identified these figures in their generations were wrong…and my generation alone is right…and when the world changes and your identification of these figures is overturned…you lose interest in the book.  Instead, all of those previous interpretations were right…and watchfulness is a consistent thing.
This isn’t a book written just to the last generation…but it also isn’t just a book written o the first generation.  It is a book written to the 7 churches…which is John’s way of representing the entire church.

Everything after this got cut and isn’t on the MP3

So let’s wrap up with a case study on how to go there and back again.  Lets look briefly at what might be the most difficult and controversial text in the book.  It is so obtuse and difficult, we had actually planned to skip over it.  It is so difficult that I read no fewer than 8 commentators and no 2 of them agreed on what this was all about.  The trumpets.  In particular, trumpet 5 and 6.
Rev 9:3 Then from the smoke came locusts on the earth, and they were given power like the power of scorpions of the earth… 6 And in those days people will seek death and will not find it. They will long to die, but death will flee from them.
7 In appearance the locusts were like horses prepared for battle: on their heads were what looked like crowns of gold; their faces were like human faces, 8 their hair like women's hair, and their teeth like lions' teeth; 9 they had breastplates like breastplates of iron, and the noise of their wings was like the noise of many chariots with horses rushing into battle. 10 They have tails and stings like scorpions, and their power to hurt people for five months is in their tails. 11 They have as king over them the angel of the bottomless pit. His name in Hebrew is Abaddon, and in Greek he is called Apollyon.
13 Then the sixth angel blew his trumpet, and I heard a voice from the four horns of the golden altar before God, 14 saying to the sixth angel who had the trumpet, “Release the four angels who are bound at the great river Euphrates.” 15 So the four angels, who had been prepared for the hour, the day, the month, and the year, were released to kill a third of mankind. 16 The number of mounted troops was twice ten thousand times ten thousand; I heard their number. 17 And this is how I saw the horses in my vision and those who rode them: they wore breastplates the color of fire and of sapphire and of sulfur, and the heads of the horses were like lions' heads, and fire and smoke and sulfur came out of their mouths. 18 By these three plagues a third of mankind was killed, by the fire and smoke and sulfur coming out of their mouths. 19 For the power of the horses is in their mouths and in their tails, for their tails are like serpents with heads, and by means of them they wound.
Now, what do many modern interpreters see when they read these chapters.  Helicopters.  Drones.

But ask yourself, what might this have meant to the 7 churches.
What are the clues.  Well, there is a lot of talk about horses….and one very important phrase:
“Release the four angels who are bound at the great river Euphrates.”

The Euphrates was the border between the two great empires: Rome and the Parthians (the ancient Persians[1]).  The Parthians lurked as a shadow of fear just beyond the Euphrates for Rome’s near eastern territories.  The Romans and Parthians battled for ancient near eastern territories for hundreds of years.  And the terror of the Parthians were their mounted Calvary:

The Parthians had developed a devastating military innovation.  They had learned horsemenship from the steppe peoples to their east…those who would become the Mongols…but the learned how to work steal from the Romans.  So they fielded an armored cavalry of archers who could fire from armored horseback.  They were called the cataphracts, and they were terrifying.  A terrifying military power building on the eastern border.

So what about the helicopters and tanks?  Well in every generation, these have been read as the ‘building army just beyond the Euphrates.’  The specter of a foreign conqueror that strikes fear.  In just the last 100 years it has been Iraq, Iran, Communism, and now, it is terrorism we fear…a great army to the east.  So as these threats have come and gone, has every generation been wrong. 

One commentator says– John “lavishes detail on the locust”…these almost mechanical locusts – many see modern machines (helicopters)… “We too have seen terrible machines in our day: monsters, whether helicopters or other military equipment, designed…to strike terror into human hearts for the sake of power and empire.  Who is to say that such machines do not ultimate come, like these insects-on-steroids…from the bottomless pit, under the direction of Apollyon?” 87

And are those in our generation who are identifying the riders and the locust as machines of military power wrong?  Not really.  John saw the Parthian Cataphract.  But there will always be a terrifying army building on our borders with scary new military technology.  In essence, every generation, who saw the locus and the hoard in their generation has been right.  It is the military power that causes you to fear. 

In Roman Asia minor, it was the Parthian riders who had seemingly mystical skills to rain down ordinance from armored horseback.  And X feared the Visagoths, Luther feared the power of the church in Rome, Hal Lindsey feared the communists, Many today fear terrorists, Syrian Christians right now fear both Assad and the rebels…many non-western Christains fear the US and/or China…we fear the other political party…and my children will fear people and armies that I could not conceive of yet.  We all have different Parthian raiders.  But there will always be Parthian raiders…until there aren’t. 

For us it might be ideological bombers – terrorists who infiltrate our public spaces (or maybe what you fear is the other political party).  And Jesus is saying, yeah, they may run you through.  The world is full of powers (cosmic and human and the feedback between them) that can do you damage.  But those that belog to the Lamb cannot really be damaged.  The lamb wins through self giving to death.  His people should not fear natural disaster, , or the Parthian horde.  They are not immune to them, but can overcome through the victory of the slaughtered lamb.

Is Revelation about the past or the future…or the present.  Yes!
 


[1] 247 BC to 224 AD

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Autonomy, Freedom, and a Giant Ape: John 8


MP3
Note: This talk changed considerably between this draft and the actual talk.  I posted this draft because of the extended exposition about Jesus’ identity.
“No one of Consequence.”
“Really I must know.”
“Get used to disappointment.”
“Who are you?”  There comes a point in a lot of narratives, where the identity of the protagonist is ambiguous.  We know he or she is special, but we haven’t really put all the pieces together.  And so the author just has one of the other characters straight up ask “Who…are…you?”

It happens in excellent, quirky, indi, comedies with great sound tracks (Garden State):
“Who are you?” “I’m your new friend Sam.”
It happens in big budget superhero pics
“Who are you?”  “I’m Batman.”

And it happens in John chapter 8. 
You see, in this passage, Jesus is being grilled and its not pretty.  This would be a little bit like doing a cable news interview with someone who disagrees with you.

They are him with leading questions trying to get him to say something embarrassing that will become a viral youtube clip.  In this chapter, they ask him 8 questions including some dusies…
I mean right out of the gate the ask stuff that is inappropriate and awkward (e.g. are you suicidal?)…but as the conversation progresses…things escalate:
“Wow that escalated quickly” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_TKpyCQOKlU
For example, in verse 41…they say “We were not born of sexual immorality…” 
Ouch...  Do you get that…  Do you see what they did there…
They are saying “hey dude, at least we know our Daddys.”
And then they ask my favorite question…
“Are we not right in saying that you are a Samaritan and have a demon?”
I mean who says stuff like that?  That either requires intentional, heedless demegogery for effect...

or a total lack of tact and self awareness...hough Dwight would ask it in a more creative way (Slide)…”

I love Jesus’ answer: “I do not have a demon…”  You can almost see him shaking his head, like, “seriously.”
It is an aggressive conversation which, like so many conversations we see around us and, especially on the stuff that passes for news on television…is more interested in generating a damning sound bite than it is in generating actual understanding.
But there is one point in the conversation, where Jesus kind of rattles them to the point that they just ask the obvious question…
“So they Said to him, “Who are you?”
But the answer he gives them is startling, and complicated, and he doesn’t just answer the who question, but also presses the why and what questions..
In John 8 Jesus answers three questions:
1.   Who he is
2.   Why that matters
3.   What you should do about it
Jesus gives two answers to the
First he says
24“I told you that you would die in your sins, for unless you believe that I am he you will die in your sins?”
And so the first cue Jesus drops about his identify is a puzzle. You see, there is a lot that could have elicited a response in Jesus’ words…telling people ”you will die in your sins” is not exactly the road to being voted prom king.  But most commentators agree that the phrase that would have grabbed their attention and drew the identity question out of them is …“I am he”
Um what? 
That sentence has no content. 
The direct object of that sentence is entirely uninformative. 
I mean thank you captain obvious. 
Or at least that is the way we hear it.  But a 1st century Jewish scholar who would have large portions of the OT memorized in the popular Greek translation of the day would have heard something very different in that phrase.
The phrase “I am he” (ego eimi) is the exact phrase Yahweh uses to refer to himself throughout the prophetic literature in their Bibles.  It makes them pause, squint a little, and ask a real question.
And then he drops it again in v 28
So Jesus said to them, When you have lifted up the Son of Man, then you will know that I am he.”
The religious teachers don’t take this well, as you might imagine.  And they begin to ask a series of increasingly offensive questions…but eventually, Jesus brings the conversation back from the things they want to talk about to the thing they should want to talk about by dropping this gem in verse 51:
If anyone keeps my word, he will never see death.
Well, this time, they aren’t confused, they are pissed.  They start ranting at him…and eventually say (v 53)
Who do you make yourself out to be?
Essentially, they are saying “Who do you think you are?” which is phrased like a question…it has the punctuation of a question, and the inflection of a question, I mean your voice goes up at the end like it’s a question, but when someone says “who do you think you are?” its not a question.  Yet Jesus answers it…in verse 57 he says:
Before Abraham was, I am?
Excuse me, What?  Now he’s just talking funny.  I mean the tenses of his verbs don’t even agree.
Before Abraham was, I am?
I mean I realize in our context, verb tenses don’t matter much anymore…
“I has cheeseburger”   “I am America (and so can you!)”
But, I mean that sentence doesn’t make sense. 
Before Abraham was, I am?
It seems like some kind of word salad…until you hear it as one of Jesus’ opponents would have heard it. 
You see, in the Hebrew Scriptures “I am” is not just a verb…it’s also a proper noun. 

When Moses encounters God at the burning bush in Exodus 3…and asks him the “who are you”…how does God answer…I AM.  Jesus isn’t talking funny, he’s saying the most offensive thing he could possibly say, in the most clever winsome way he could possibly say it. 
Jesus is unambiguously identifying himself as Yahweh, the God of the Hebrew scriptures.  It may seem like coded language to us, but it could not have been more stark or plainly stated in the spiritual idiom of that day.  And if that is not clear enough from the text itself, it is clear from the context, because in verse 59 those listening to him immediately pick up stones.  Whatever he said in this grammatically awkward English sentence…it was grounds to get stoned…and not in the fun way.
But the passage is also confusing, because while Jesus is unambiguously identifying himself as God, he also clearly distinguishes himself from “the Father” several times.
The way DA Carson put it…

And, it turns out, that the answer to the question “who are you” goes waaay deeper than they could have imagined.  You see, if you want to know who Jesus claims to be, you need to do business with John chapter 8…you have to do business with Trinity.
In the history of the church, there have been those who have wanted to stress God’s unity – getting rid of the messy distinctions between Jesus, Father and Spirit, collapsing them to metaphors for the same single reality.  And there have been others who have wanted to de-emphasize the unity of the three, by making Jesus just a dude who served God in a special way and the spirit some cosmic force between them.  But throughout its history, the church has refused both of those tidy solutions…because neither is faithful to the complexity o f Jesus’ self understanding.  

 

And so, The Chalcedonianian creed, which is recognized by all major flavors of Christianity (Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant) asserts that the Father, Jesus, and the Spirit are God 'without confusion' and 'without separation'.
  
SK - “He is the paradox that history can never digest or convert into an ordinary syllogism.” p 30[3]

-Is Jesus Yahweh of the Hebrew Scriptures…YES. 
-Is he distinct from ‘the Father’…YES. 
   -Does that cook your noodle…YES. 
   -Should God be entirely penetrable by the electrical impulses of 4 lb masses of gooey carbon…NO.

2. Mission: 
So in the middle of this debate, Jesus’ interlocutors stop asking weird questions long enough for Jesus to tell a little parable, which is the most famous part of this passage by a long shot.  In verse 31-36 he says:
31So Jesus said to the Jews who had believed him, “If you abide in my word, you are truly my disciples, 32and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” 33They answered him, “We are offspring of Abraham and have never been enslaved to anyone. How is it that you say, ‘You will become free’?”
34Jesus answered them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, everyone who practices sin is a slave to sin. 35The slave does not remain in the house forever; the son remains forever. 36So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.
Well, it’s because theology matters…because understanding Jesus’ identity is the key to understanding Jesus’ mission…and our response.
The point behind his identity is that he is qualified to rescue
Disney recently bought the rights to a science fiction novel I finished last month called Incarceron.  Early reports are that they are going to place the film adaptation in the hands of a werewolf and a wolverine. 



But in this story there is a prison from which there is no escape.  And the slaves in this prison have been there so long that they forget it is a prison and have stopped believing that an outside world exists.
There is this great line in the middle of the book, where one of the characters describes the situation:
"Most men are content to live in their prison and think it is their world." (6:8)

And I love this picture, because it is precisely the way the conversation between Jesus and his interviewers goes down.  He says
The truth will set you free.
And his opponents get testy and shoot back.
We have never been enslaved.
Now, Jesus stays on course, because, frankly he loves them, and wants to tell them how they can be free…but if it was me getting interviewed, Right here is the point where I’d start to get sarcastic.  I’d be like, REALLY?   You’ve NEVER been slaves? SERIOUSLY?  So I’m totally imagining those Roman soldiers standing over there.  And before that, the Seleucid empire…and what about Alexander the great…oh, and I suppose Assyria and Babylon let you do whatever you want when they marched you out away from your family and lands and pressed you  into labor.   I mean, at this point, the Hebrews had been politically autonomous for precisely 1 generation in the last 1000 years.  They had been conquered and re-conquered and owned and oppressed…yet they look at Jesus with a straight face, and say…”dude, I don’t know what you are talking about…we’ve never been slaves”…but Jesus presses them…he asks them for some real self examination:
If you practice sin, you are a slave to sin.
He argues that most of us are enslaved to the half loves and broken promises of the appetites and authorities we live for.  Our autonomy is illusion.  We dance.  We dance for the things, or appetites, or people who have power over us…because…
"Most men are content to live in their prison and think it is their world." (6:8)
And then Jesus leverages the imagery of the Roman slave market…an imagery probably most familiar to us from the film Gladiator…and says
The slave does not remain in the house forever; the son remains forever.  So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.
Jesus says, listen, slaves cannot free themselves…and they can’t free other slaves…but the Son, the co-ruler of the kingdom, he can declare you free…and more than that he can make you the heir to the kingdom you were meant to be.
So, back to the story of Incarceron.  In the world outside the prison, there is a princess, who is the only one with the power and position to enter the prison and free those who have been enslaved.
So she gives up all of her royal advantages and uses her power and position to go into the prison to extract a boy who has forgotten that he was born heir to the kingdom.  Only an heir to the kingdom had the power to undertake this transform a slave into an heir.  Only an heir to the kingdom could free the slave AND make him an heir.  The other slaves couldn’t break him free.  They couldn’t break free themselves.  Most of them had forgotten that freedom even existed.  Only the heir had the power and only the heir had the desire to free the slave.  And in the process, the slave was also reinstated as the heir to the kingdom and immediately went to work to free other slaves.
And this is how the early church Father’s described what Jesus did for us.  Our liberator could only be a God man says Athanasius…because he had to invade our reality, but he had to transcend our reality to be able to free us from it.  Only the son of the king can change our status from slave to son.   
"The Word of God, our Lord Jesus Christ, who did, through His transcendent love, become what we are, that He might bring us to be even what He is Himself." –Iranaus
“He became what we are so that he might make us what he is.” - St. Athanasius of Alexandria
We can’t be freed by other slaves…only by the son who takes on the life of the slave and then breaks it.  Like the prison in Incarceron, our prison can only be solved from the outside.  We can only be freed by an external invader.
3. Freedom Sounds Great…How do I get There?:
So how does Jesus say you access truth that leads to freedom.  Well, in the midst of a bunch of pretty confusing theology and debate, he spells it out pretty simply in verse 31.
“If you abide in my word, you are truly my disciples, and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”
A lot of people press those last six words into service.  They have been used to defend or assert nearly every ideology.  But look at that whole sentence again.  Knowing truth and being set free by it are embedded in a larger process.  Being freed by truth has two antecedent conditions.
1) abide
2) follow
3) know
4) freedom 
We throw around the “truth will set you free” phrase all the time…but it follows other stuff.  Living with and following Jesus precede freeing knowledge. Jesus isn’t just a special forces agent that sweeps in, knocks down the door, and sets you free. 
And that is because freedom requires a transfer of allegiance and a change of address.  Truth doesn’t just happen in the context of dispassionate investigation, but by ‘taking up residence’ in the words of Jesus, of building your home there…and then transferring your allegiance to him.    
My oldest daughter is five.  She started pre-school this year, and that means she has a new set of friends and a new measure of autonomy.  She is just getting used to what that means.  And so, after school last week, my wife took her to Rainbow City, the big wooden playground in N Davis to play with her new friends.  And while the moms were talking they overheard our kids talking…This is what the kids said:
“Wouldn’t it be great if our parents died?  Then we could live in rainbow city.  We could eat as much candy as we want and watch cartoons all day.”
Now, you understand the world enough to understand that the world they have concocted in their minds is not freedom.  They want autonomy.  But autonomy  does not equal freedom, because their limitations are not external.
Now, most of you are about 15 years removed from Kindergarten.  We are about half way through the School year.  Which means that the reality of what college is like is dawning on many of you freshman.  And maybe some of you upper classmen are at a point of reassessment.  You came to college with a sense that your life would be totally changed with all of the new freedom that you would get.  And let me ask you.  How’s that going for you? 
I find that a lot of students find that coming to college and losing the constraints that their parents house put on their lives…well it’s not the same as being free. 
Autonomy isn’t the same as freedom.  Because, according to Jesus, your constraints aren’t external.  You bring your captors wherever you go. 
Because whoever practices sin is a slave to sin.
Conclusion: “Stockholm syndrome.”
So why is it that “practicing sin” as Jesus puts it, enslaves us? 
And why is it that transferring our allegiance and really orienting our lives around Jesus (either for the first time or the 10,000th) fundamentally freeing?
Let me give you a 3 word answer: “The Stockholm Effect”
Becoming so accustomed to your slavery that you begin to perceive it as benevolent...or even better than ‘freedom.’  Most recently is the central plot point of the show “Homeland”…but classically it is fundamental to the story of King Kong.  You know that classic tale of:
Ape abducts woman.
Ape terrifies and abuses woman.
Woman loves ape.
I remember the week that the latest version of King Kong came out.  I was at kinkos and the guy who was helping me was a film nerd and we got talking about it…and he started telling me all the reasons this film (which I thought was borderline unwatchable) was artistically excellent…it was really interesting…but then he said this, “But, my girlfriend just couldn’t get into it…you know the Stockholm effect.”
And that was my experience of the movie…when Naomi Watts was gazing lovingly into the face of this beast who had caused her so much terror and pain…I just thought….REALLY!!!???!!! 


That’s not sweet…that’s a complete loss of connection with reality.
It is self selected slavery through the mechanism of self delusion.
That is a picture of us…gazing lovingly into the eyes of our violent, ugly captor, forgetting what we were actually made for…we get attached to the things that enslave us that we forget that someone grabing us and dragging us up the empire state building is not loving behavior.
The ape doesn’t love you…you are its slave.
The ape doesn’t love you…and neither do your grades, or your crushes, or those naked girls on your computer screen, or you professional dream…they don’t love you.  But if you serve them, they own you.
If you love your grades and dreams, if you live for your professional aspirations or crushes, if you orient your life around the things you want, they will eventually come to own you.  These things can drive our decisions and behaviors.  And we don’t even notice.  They enslave us, and we thank them.[8] 
But Jesus says, Transfer your allegiance to me…and then orient your life around me…follow and abide…and the fabric of reality will start to become clear…the things that are worth living for will begin to become apparent.  You will begin to see that the thing that you are living for, that you gaze lovingly at, that it is the big ugly mug of an ape that has no interest in your joy or welfare.  But Jesus does.
And that truth will set you free.
________
[1] An interesting phrase with intentionally ambiguous referent (to his death and resurrection).  Carson: “One of the functions of the cross is t reveal  who Jesus is.”
[2] So, theologically, you have three choices, First, you can stress the unity of Jesus as God and ignore the distinction…or Second you can stress the distinction and overlook Jesus’ claims to divinity…or you can take both seriously.  And that is how the early church decided to deal with the tension in this passage.  The doctrine of the Trinity doesn’t so much as explain how Jesus and the Father and the Spirit are the all God yet distinct…rather, it simply asserts that they are.  And attempts to push them together or separate them
[3] “It is  hard to believe because it is hard to obey.” Also SK This actually gets at a lot of the epistemology embedded in Jesus’ questions in this passage…epistemology that I had to cut.
[4] FF Bruce calls this passage a “parenthetical parable.”  It seems like a diversion.  What is it doing in the middle of a passage so clearly about Jesus’ identity.
[5] His body was for Him not a limitation, but an instrument, so that He was both in it and in all things, and outside all things, resting in the Father above. At one and the same time- this is the wonder - as man He was an human life, and as Word He was sustaining the life of the universe, and as Son He was in constant union with the Father” – Athanasius
[6] Now we just wrapped up a series on ‘becoming God’s best version of you’ where we followed what Paul had to say about how to change.  And if you remember, Paul put the command to:
“Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly” along side “Put to death whatever is earthly in you.”
Shaking lose the degrading habits and practices happens in the context of a rule of life…of abiding with Jesus.
[7] Let him move you from slavery to sonship, both ontologically but also experientially. 
[8] AD wrote this, and I couldn’t fit it, but I loved it: I may have written this before but I never understood why every time I turned in a test in college I would put the piece of paper in front of the professor and say, “Thank you.”  I couldn’t stop myself! I would walk away every time and think, “You idiot. Why did you thank her. She just destroyed you with that test.  And you thanked her for it.”  But even after a few times realizing this, I would tell myself that I wouldn’t say thank you as I was walking up, but whenever I got there, I always did.